How to Read a Zoning Bylaw: Part 3 – Building Height

Carl Funk, MCIP RPP

—

5–7 minutes
Vancouver high rise building representing building height limits in zoning.

In Part 1 of this series, we looked at how to find your property’s zoning, understand the intent of the zone and determine whether your proposed use is allowed.

In Part 2, we dove into density.

Here, we are going to talk about height.

At first glance, height is one of the more straightforward parts of a zoning bylaw. Find the maximum height, compare it to what you want to build, and move on.

Usually, it is fairly simple. But there are a few nuances worth understanding.

Let’s get into it.

Start With the Height Limit

Most zoning bylaws regulate building height in one of three ways:

  • metres or feet;
  • number of storeys; or
  • some combination of the two.

For example, the City of Burnaby’s E1 zone for employment uses has a height limit of eight storeys. Similarly, Coquitlam’s M-1 zone limits buildings to six storeys.

In these examples the height is limited by the number of storeys, floors or levels in the building. There isn’t a specific measurement in terms of feet or metres to cap the height for these zones. But that doesn’t mean these cities don’t also use fixed height measured in feet and metres.

For example, in Coquitlam, the City has certain areas that can not go above 55 metres. This restriction is found in a schedule/appendix of their zoning bylaw.

The reason I bring this up is because there may be multiple layers of height restrictions in the zoning bylaw. And these different layers may use different measurements to restrict building height.

Ok, let’s address the next question that usually comes up.

How Tall Is a Storey?

Here’s where things can get a little less obvious.

A storey doesn’t necessarily have a defined height in metres or feet. Instead, it generally refers to a complete floor or level of a building.

As always, check the definitions in the applicable zoning bylaw. Make sure you understand how a storey is defined.

A single level industrial building in Metro Vancouver can reasonably be over 40 feet tall. Retail floors on mixed use buildings can be over 15 feet while residential floors on apartment buildings are typically closer to 9 feet going higher for the penthouse units.

I remember working on a project in White Rock where we were proposing a 14-storey building. Some members of the community focused heavily on the number of storeys and suggested that the building should instead be reduced to 12 storeys, pointing to another nearby building as a comparison.

The interesting part was that the 12-storey building they were referencing was actually about the same physical height as our proposed 14-storey building. It had very generous floor-to-floor heights, particularly at the lower levels. So was the community worried about the actual height? or the number of storeys?

Does a Mezzanine Count as a Storey?

This one comes up regularly, particularly with industrial and commercial buildings.

You might have a zone that permits a maximum of two storeys and be looking at a building with a ground floor, second floor and mezzanine.

Is that two storeys or three?

The Building Code will have a more clear answer on the definition of a mezzanine. Unfortunately that is not always the case for zoning bylaw definitions.

In many cases the clarification and definition is missing, and I’ve seen different interpretations. I’ve heard some argue a mezzanine is a storey as per the zoning bylaw when there was no clarification, and other times saying its not.

What about basements?

Basements, believe it or not, can count as storeys depending on the City.

The lesson is to check the definition first and then confirm early. This can be a fun argument to have with the regulators. I wish you good luck.

From Where Is Height Actually Measured?

If height is restricted in feet or metres, the next question is:

Where do you measure from?

This is especially important on sloping sites.

To figure this out, you’ll typically need to move beyond the specific zone and flip (or scroll to) the bylaw’s general provisions, definitions or rules of measurement.

Depending on the municipality, building height might be measured from:

  • average grade;
  • finished grade;
  • natural or existing grade;
  • a calculated grade around the building;
  • a specified geodetic elevation; or
  • another reference point established by the bylaw.

These differences can matter.

A 12-metre height limit doesn’t tell you everything if you don’t know where that 12 metres starts and where it ends.

What Can Project Above the Height Limit?

Another thing I look for is whether there are any exceptions to the maximum building height.

Depending on the bylaw, certain building elements may be allowed to project above the stated height limit. These might include:

  • elevator overruns;
  • stair enclosures;
  • mechanical equipment;
  • rooftop mechanical rooms;
  • parapets;
  • guardrails;
  • antennas;
  • chimneys; or
  • other rooftop structures.

I have heard of a couple horror storeys where the architect assumed the elevator overrun was allowed to extend beyond the height limit. Turns out, it wasn’t. The result was a losing an entire floor from what the developer had planned for.

The specific exemptions vary by municipality, so check the bylaw carefully.

I also like to specifically ask the architect what height exclusions or projections may be available.

View Cones

I’m not giving this topic as much time as it deserves but am bringing it up just so you are aware. In some cities, there is another layer of restriction to height. View Cones.

Vancouver is a good example.

The City protects certain public views through view corridors, commonly referred to as view cones. Depending on the location of a property, these policies can establish another height constraint beyond what you might initially identify in the zoning regulations.

That means a zoning bylaw might appear to allow a certain building height, but another layer of policy could further restrict what can actually be built.

A Few Things to Check

I want to leave you with a checklist of questions I ask when reviewing height limits in a zoning bylaw:

  • What is the maximum permitted height?
  • Is height regulated in metres or feet, storeys, or both?
  • From what point is height measured?
  • How is grade defined and calculated?
  • How is the top of the building determined?
  • Are there exceptions for rooftop equipment, elevators or stairs?
  • How are mezzanines treated?
  • How are basements or partially buried floors treated?
  • Are there additional site-specific height restrictions, such as view corridors?
  • Can the permitted density actually fit within the available height and building envelope?

Want to Develop Your Property?

If you’re considering developing a property and need help understanding its potential, SiteMentor Development Consultants can help assess your development options, identify key risks, review the financial viability and provide greater clarity before you move forward.

Development Calculators


Metro Vancouver DCC Calculator

Estimate regional DCCs for your project.


Preliminary Proforma

Quickly test returns based on preliminary cost assumptions.


Land Value Calculator

Estimate what a site may be worth using the residual land value method.

Carl Funk

I help property owners, developers, and professionals navigate the real estate development process through consulting, coaching, and practical lessons.

LATEST POSTS

Carl Funk

Principal | SiteMentor Development Consultants

Avoid Costly Development Mistakes

Weekly insights to help property owners, developers, and aspiring professionals make smarter development decisions.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.