The Development Mistake I See Again and Again

Carl Funk, MCIP RPP

—

3–4 minutes
Cranes representing crane-swing and encroachment agreements.

I remember advising a firm that had already closed on a site.

When I joined the project, the design approvals were largely in hand.
Consultants were well advanced.

The construction budget looked tight but workable.

On paper, the project was showing a reasonable return.

The project included an underground parking lot that extended right to the property lines. This is very common but often requires agreements with neighbours to excavate in the most cost-effective manner.

So I asked a straightforward question:

“Have you secured the encroachment agreements from the neighbours?”

Silence.

They hadn’t.
They hadn’t started discussions.
They weren’t even certain they needed agreements.

And in that moment, a project that looked clean started to become a little shaky.

This firm was not inexperienced and, unfortunately, this was not the first time I’ve seen this issue come up late.


What Is an Encroachment Agreement? (Plainly)

At its simplest, an encroachment agreement is:

Permission to use land (typically next to you site) you don’t own.

In development, that usually shows up as:

  • Shoring tiebacks drilled into adjacent soil during excavation
  • Crane swing over neighbouring airspace
  • Scaffolding or temporary access beyond your lot line

Often the use is temporary during construction.

If your project design and construction plan extends beyond your property, even underground, you need consent. Otherwise it’s trespassing.

And that consent typically comes through a negotiated legal agreement.


Why Does This Matter?

Your acquisition price and pro forma likely assumed the most efficient construction approach.

  • Shoring with anchor rods instead of piling.
  • Full underground parking.
  • Most efficiently placed crane location.

But those methods can depend on cooperation from neighbours.

If that cooperation isn’t secured, there are alternatives.

You can:

  • Redesign the shoring to a pile design
  • Reduce underground scope
  • Phase excavation

All technically solvable.

But, were they reflected in your land value at time of purchase?

Did you test the purchase price using different assumptions? Many don’t.

When encroachment risk is discovered after acquisition, or worse, during construction planning, it doesn’t just create inconvenience.


Consider the Timing

Encroachment agreements can involve:

  • Legal drafting
  • Insurance requirements
  • Indemnities
  • Monitoring conditions
  • Compensation

They are not trivial.

These can become big problems when it’s discovered too late.

Because timing determines leverage.

Early in the process, you have options:

  • Test neighbour receptiveness
  • Budget contingencies properly
  • Explore alternate design paths
  • Structure agreements thoughtfully
  • Adjust underwriting and purchase price if you can

Late in the process, your options narrow.

And leverage shifts.


Figure This Out Early

On projects where encroachment risk was flagged early, negotiations were measured and professional. Even when compensation was required, it was incorporated deliberately.

On projects where it surfaced late, urgency crept in.

At that point, the neighbour understands your position.

The project may still proceed.

But at a cost that wasn’t originally modeled.


The Most Important Advice

It’s so important, I’ll say it one more time: Flag it early, before acquisition.

Not to alarm your team.
Not to overcomplicate acquisition.
But to create room to strategize.

During early site review, ask:

  • Will excavation require tiebacks beyond the property line?
  • Does crane swing extend into adjacent airspace?
  • Is temporary access required beyond your lot?
  • Does the assumed construction methodology rely on neighbour cooperation?

If the answer is “possibly,” that’s enough.

That’s your signal to pause and assess.

You don’t need every answer immediately.

You need awareness early enough to preserve optionality.


Final Thought

Most development problems are manageable when identified early.

Encroachment agreements are no different.

They don’t usually kill projects.

But when ignored, they quietly erode profit margin, schedule, and negotiating position.

Flag early.
Create options.
Negotiate from a stable position…not in panic mode.

Could Your Project Benefit From Expert Guidance?

If you’d like confidence before moving forward, SiteMentor Development Consultants provide industry-best development feasibility reports that identify what your property can realistically support, highlights potential constraints, and helps you determine the development strategy that makes the most sense for your goals.

Development Calculators


Metro Vancouver DCC Calculator

Estimate regional DCCs for your project.


Preliminary Proforma

Quickly test returns based on preliminary cost assumptions.


Land Value Calculator

Estimate what a site may be worth using the residual land value method.

Carl Funk

I help property owners, developers, and professionals navigate the real estate development process through consulting, coaching, and practical lessons.

LATEST POSTS

Carl Funk

Principal | SiteMentor Development Consultants

Avoid Costly Development Mistakes

Weekly insights to help property owners, developers, and aspiring professionals make smarter development decisions.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.