Early in my career, I worked on a project in a waterfront community where views were a defining feature of the neighbourhood. Residents cared deeply about them, and for good reason.
Our proposal challenged the zoning bylaws.
Instead of a shorter, bulkier building that fit within the existing zoning envelope, we proposed something different: a taller, slender building. It exceeded the height limit by a few floors, but the footprint was significantly reduced…narrower than the setbacks allowed.
The reaction was immediate…and to be honest, we sort of expected it.
“Taller buildings block views.”
“Typical greedy developers.”
“Why can’t you just follow the zoning?”
Those responses weren’t surprising. Height is quickly criticized.
But what often gets lost in the dialogue is that every design proposal has trade-offs.
In this case, the slender form was intentional. By reducing the building width, we preserved more view corridors between buildings. The smaller footprint also created more public-realm space at ground level — wider sidewalks, better landscaping opportunities, and room for things like sidewalk cafes and patios.
The wider sidewalks and opportunities for sidewalk cafes is what I was most excited for. I love wide sidewalks. We were proposing retail space on the ground floor, and we believed the additional pedestrian space was vital to making the commercial units attractive. Personally, I’ll take a wide sidewalk over a narrow one every time, and this community needed it.
Of course, the additional height wasn’t arbitrary either. The extra floors were necessary to make the project financially viable. Without them, the narrower building, which produced less floorplate area, simply wouldn’t work financially.
So the real choice wasn’t between “good” and “bad” design. It was between two different sets of compromises:
- Shorter but bulkier
- Taller but slimmer
- Standard sidewalks or expanded public realm
- Strict zoning compliance or minor variance with public-realm benefits
Once framed that way, we started having a little more success.
The City ultimately supported the proposal, not because everyone agreed with the design, but because the trade-offs aligned with broader community objectives — protecting views where possible, improving the pedestrian environment, and delivering a viable project.
That experience reinforced something I’ve seen repeatedly in real estate development:
The quality of your project is often determined by how well you understand and communicate trade-offs. Every project and design has trade-offs. Pros and cons.
If you can clearly explain:
- What you’re asking for; and
- What the community gains in return,
you might have a chance to move the conversation from clear opposition to understanding and problem solving.
A few practical tips
1. Identify your trade-offs early
During due diligence and concept design, write down what you’re asking for and what you’re giving up. Height for open space. Density for affordability. Variance for public realm improvements. This early work sets you up for communication success later down the road.
2. Connect decisions to the community vision
Official Community Plans, neighbourhood plans, and urban design guidelines often emphasize outcomes like walkability, livability, and public space quality. Show how your trade-offs support those goals, even if your building form looks different from what people expect.
3. Don’t assume the trade-offs are obvious
What feels logical to a development team may not be obvious to residents seeing a proposal for the first time. Take the time to explain the “why,” not just the “what.” The community members don’t have time to dive deep into the rationale. You need to do the work for them. If you can’t explain the trade offs clearly, don’t expect others to understand your project.
At the end of the day, you won’t be able to eliminating all negative impacts. But, you can balancing your design in a way that creates more benefit than cost.
There’s rarely a perfect solution. But there is usually a better-balanced one.
And often, the difference comes down to how well you plan for, and communicate the trade-offs.
Could Your Project Benefit From Expert Guidance?
If you’d like confidence before moving forward, SiteMentor Development Consultants provide industry-best development feasibility reports that identify what your property can realistically support, highlights potential constraints, and helps you determine the development strategy that makes the most sense for your goals.


